Top Picks
MONTGOMERY WARD Mens White & Black Patterned Shirt L Classic Long Sleeve Button
NATE’S PICK CERQULARMONTGOMERY WARD Mens White & Black Patterned Shirt L Classic Long Sleeve Button
$51.99 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens Green Plain Relaxed Fit Shirt 2XL Long Sleeve Button Down Oxford
CODY’S PICK CERQULARNAUTICA Mens Green Plain Relaxed Fit Shirt 2XL Long Sleeve Button Down Oxford
$18.19 CERQULAR
NATURAL ISSUE Mens Green & Navy Stripe Button Down Shirt XL Classic Fit
ADE’S PICK CERQULARNATURAL ISSUE Mens Green & Navy Stripe Button Down Shirt XL Classic Fit
$19.49 CERQULAR
SUNSET Mens Black & Orange Pattern Shirt L Vintage Style Polyester Long Sleeve
CALLUM’S PICK CERQULARSUNSET Mens Black & Orange Pattern Shirt L Vintage Style Polyester Long Sleeve
$19.49 CERQULAR
PALERMO Mens Beige & Brown Pattern Shirt L Cotton Blend Long Sleeve
JAKE’S PICK CERQULARPALERMO Mens Beige & Brown Pattern Shirt L Cotton Blend Long Sleeve
$15.59 CERQULAR
How we pick

These picks came from Nate, Cody, Ade, Callum and Jake, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

SASKA Mens Brown & White Polka Dot Shirt XL Long Sleeve Button Up Retro
CERQULAR

SASKA Mens Brown & White Polka Dot Shirt XL Long Sleeve Button Up Retro

$19.49 CERQULAR
PALERMO Mens Beige & Brown Pattern Shirt L Cotton Blend Long Sleeve
CERQULAR

PALERMO Mens Beige & Brown Pattern Shirt L Cotton Blend Long Sleeve

$15.59 CERQULAR
Want even more options?46vintage formal shirts from 11 shops in the Fashion FinderSee them all →
MARINER Mens White Patterned Shirt L Cotton Blend Artistic Print
CERQULAR

MARINER Mens White Patterned Shirt L Cotton Blend Artistic Print

$19.49 CERQULAR
Steampunk Shirt With Chic Neckline
SELDOM SEEN STYLES

Steampunk Shirt With Chic Neckline

$46.00 SELDOM SEEN STYLES
ARROW Mens Green Polyester Blend Shirt M Classic Mach II Button Front Long
CERQULAR

ARROW Mens Green Polyester Blend Shirt M Classic Mach II Button Front Long

$16.89 CERQULAR
TREMOLA Mens Black Floral Check Shirt S Cotton Blend Stylish Patterned
CERQULAR

TREMOLA Mens Black Floral Check Shirt S Cotton Blend Stylish Patterned

$19.49 CERQULAR
Dark in Love Gothic Peter Pan Collar Lace Shirt - Dark Academia Striped Cotton
CRONJAGER

Dark in Love Gothic Peter Pan Collar Lace Shirt - Dark Academia Striped Cotton

$29.99 CRONJAGER
Black Cotton Button Up Shirt with Gold Embroidered Key Motif
THESUPERMADE INC

Black Cotton Button Up Shirt with Gold Embroidered Key Motif

$64.99 THESUPERMADE INC
BANYAN Mens Blue Maroon & Yellow Checked Shirt L Classic Nylon Long Sleeve
CERQULAR

BANYAN Mens Blue Maroon & Yellow Checked Shirt L Classic Nylon Long Sleeve

$19.49 CERQULAR
MONTGOMERY WARD Mens White & Black Patterned Shirt L Classic Long Sleeve Button
CERQULAR

MONTGOMERY WARD Mens White & Black Patterned Shirt L Classic Long Sleeve Button

$51.99 CERQULAR
NATURAL ISSUE Mens Green & Navy Stripe Button Down Shirt XL Classic Fit
CERQULAR

NATURAL ISSUE Mens Green & Navy Stripe Button Down Shirt XL Classic Fit

$19.49 CERQULAR
Mens Brown Pattern Plaid Cotton Shirt M Casual Retro Vintage Button Collar
CERQULAR

Mens Brown Pattern Plaid Cotton Shirt M Casual Retro Vintage Button Collar

$15.59 CERQULAR
CAMBRIDGE CLASSICS Mens Navy Blue Shirt L Cotton Blend Casual Button Down
CERQULAR

CAMBRIDGE CLASSICS Mens Navy Blue Shirt L Cotton Blend Casual Button Down

$19.49 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens Green Plain Relaxed Fit Shirt 2XL Long Sleeve Button Down Oxford
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens Green Plain Relaxed Fit Shirt 2XL Long Sleeve Button Down Oxford

$18.19 CERQULAR
SUNSET Mens Black & Orange Pattern Shirt L Vintage Style Polyester Long Sleeve
CERQULAR

SUNSET Mens Black & Orange Pattern Shirt L Vintage Style Polyester Long Sleeve

$19.49 CERQULAR
Mens Beige Patterned Shirt Button Long Sleeve L Vintage Style Casual
CERQULAR

Mens Beige Patterned Shirt Button Long Sleeve L Vintage Style Casual

$15.59 CERQULAR