Top Picks
NIKE Mens Grey Colts Crew Neck XL Sweatshirt Cotton Blend Pullover Sportswear
KEVIN’S PICK CERQULARNIKE Mens Grey Colts Crew Neck XL Sweatshirt Cotton Blend Pullover Sportswear
$41.59 CERQULAR
Eliana Long Sleeve Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 1X - 14W-16W / Purple Orchid
LUIS’ PICK THREADED PEAREliana Long Sleeve Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 1X - 14W-16W / Purple Orchid
$45.99 THREADED PEAR
Rosalee Cuffs Long Sleeve PLUS Sweatshirt - 2X - 18W-20W / Khaki Stripe
CODY’S PICK THREADED PEARRosalee Cuffs Long Sleeve PLUS Sweatshirt - 2X - 18W-20W / Khaki Stripe
$52.99 THREADED PEAR
Taylor Striped Oversized Sweatshirt
DEREK’S PICK THREADED PEARTaylor Striped Oversized Sweatshirt
$45.99 THREADED PEAR
Rose Stripe Crew Neck Pullover Sweatshirt
MARCUS’ PICK THREADED PEARRose Stripe Crew Neck Pullover Sweatshirt
$39.99 THREADED PEAR
How we pick

These picks came from Kevin, Luis, Cody, Derek and Marcus, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5022 pieces
CHAPS Striped Mens Sweatshirt Black 1/4 Zip
CERQULAR

CHAPS Striped Mens Sweatshirt Black 1/4 Zip

$23.39 CERQULAR
Striped Mens Sweatshirt Grey 1/4 Zip
CERQULAR

Striped Mens Sweatshirt Grey 1/4 Zip

$27.29 CERQULAR
GAME Mens Red V-Neck Pullover Sweatshirt 2XL Lightweight Retro Style
CERQULAR

GAME Mens Red V-Neck Pullover Sweatshirt 2XL Lightweight Retro Style

$23.39 CERQULAR
Eliana Long Sleeve Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 1X - 14W-16W / Purple Orchid
THREADED PEAR

Eliana Long Sleeve Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 1X - 14W-16W / Purple Orchid

$45.99 THREADED PEAR
Batman Logo Knitted Sweatshirt with Striped Sleeves
TV STORE ONLINE

Batman Logo Knitted Sweatshirt with Striped Sleeves

$41.24 TV STORE ONLINE
VARSITY Mens Grey Sweatshirt Smoky Hill Buffaloco Crew Neck L Retro
CERQULAR

VARSITY Mens Grey Sweatshirt Smoky Hill Buffaloco Crew Neck L Retro

$41.59 CERQULAR
Rose Stripe Crew Neck Pullover Sweatshirt
THREADED PEAR

Rose Stripe Crew Neck Pullover Sweatshirt

$39.99 THREADED PEAR
Paige Striped Oversized Sweatshirt
THREADED PEAR

Paige Striped Oversized Sweatshirt

$45.99 THREADED PEAR
Dena Sleeve Shift Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 3X - 22W-24W / Pink Stripe
THREADED PEAR

Dena Sleeve Shift Tunic PLUS Sweatshirt - 3X - 22W-24W / Pink Stripe

$42.99 THREADED PEAR
Taylor Striped Oversized Sweatshirt
THREADED PEAR

Taylor Striped Oversized Sweatshirt

$45.99 THREADED PEAR
Liana Sleeve Loose Fit Sweatshirt - XL - 16/18 / Gray
THREADED PEAR

Liana Sleeve Loose Fit Sweatshirt - XL - 16/18 / Gray

$47.99 THREADED PEAR
CHAMPION Striped Mens Sweatshirt Blue Collared
CERQULAR

CHAMPION Striped Mens Sweatshirt Blue Collared

$25.99 CERQULAR
FILA Mens Grey Cotton Crew Neck M Sweatshirt Embroidered Logo Retro Style
CERQULAR

FILA Mens Grey Cotton Crew Neck M Sweatshirt Embroidered Logo Retro Style

$33.79 CERQULAR
NIKE Mens Grey Colts Crew Neck XL Sweatshirt Cotton Blend Pullover Sportswear
CERQULAR

NIKE Mens Grey Colts Crew Neck XL Sweatshirt Cotton Blend Pullover Sportswear

$41.59 CERQULAR
GEAR Mens White Sweatshirt XL V-Neck Cotton Blend Casual Retro Style
CERQULAR

GEAR Mens White Sweatshirt XL V-Neck Cotton Blend Casual Retro Style

$16.89 CERQULAR
Mens Blue Sweatshirt Polo Collar S Striped Zip Pockets Cotton Blend Pullover
CERQULAR

Mens Blue Sweatshirt Polo Collar S Striped Zip Pockets Cotton Blend Pullover

$27.29 CERQULAR
COLOSSEUM ATHLETICS Mens Blue & White ISU Pullover L Sweatshirt V-Neck Athletic
CERQULAR

COLOSSEUM ATHLETICS Mens Blue & White ISU Pullover L Sweatshirt V-Neck Athletic

$23.39 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Striped Mens Sweatshirt Blue 1/4 Zip 2XL
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Striped Mens Sweatshirt Blue 1/4 Zip 2XL

$28.59 CERQULAR
CHAPS Striped Mens Sweatshirt Grey 1/4 Zip
CERQULAR

CHAPS Striped Mens Sweatshirt Grey 1/4 Zip

$27.29 CERQULAR
CALVIN KLEIN Mens Red Striped 1/4 Zip Sweatshirt M Cotton Blend Stylish
CERQULAR

CALVIN KLEIN Mens Red Striped 1/4 Zip Sweatshirt M Cotton Blend Stylish

$41.59 CERQULAR
Rosalee Cuffs Long Sleeve PLUS Sweatshirt - 2X - 18W-20W / Khaki Stripe
THREADED PEAR

Rosalee Cuffs Long Sleeve PLUS Sweatshirt - 2X - 18W-20W / Khaki Stripe

$52.99 THREADED PEAR
Gothic Number Stripe Rugby Collar Sweatshirt
THESUPERMADE INC

Gothic Number Stripe Rugby Collar Sweatshirt

$86.36 THESUPERMADE INC
Worth the splurge3 pieces