Top Picks
shirt in dark blue popeline man
WALT’S PICK DRESTIGEshirt in dark blue popeline man
$263.70 DRESTIGE
CHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual Fit
GARETH’S PICK CERQULARCHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual Fit
$31.19 CERQULAR
Mesh-Paneled Satin-Embroidered Long-Sleeved Shirt
NATE’S PICK SELDOM SEEN STYLESMesh-Paneled Satin-Embroidered Long-Sleeved Shirt
$40.51 SELDOM SEEN STYLES
NAUTICA Mens Cream & Green Check Cotton Blend Shirt S Button-Down Collar Long
ADE’S PICK CERQULARNAUTICA Mens Cream & Green Check Cotton Blend Shirt S Button-Down Collar Long
$25.99 CERQULAR
RALPH LAUREN Mens White & Yellow Cotton Check Shirt L Classic Button-Down Collar
BRANDON’S PICK CERQULARRALPH LAUREN Mens White & Yellow Cotton Check Shirt L Classic Button-Down Collar
$28.59 CERQULAR
How we pick

These picks came from Walt, Gareth, Nate, Ade and Brandon, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under $5017 pieces
NAUTICA Mens Blue Cotton Blend Shirt M Classic Button-Down Long Sleeve
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens Blue Cotton Blend Shirt M Classic Button-Down Long Sleeve

$25.99 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens Red & Blue Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens Red & Blue Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual

$25.99 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens Cream & Green Check Cotton Blend Shirt S Button-Down Collar Long
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens Cream & Green Check Cotton Blend Shirt S Button-Down Collar Long

$25.99 CERQULAR
FRED PERRY Mens Blue Red Plaid Shirt S Classic Button-Down Collar Cotton Blend
CERQULAR

FRED PERRY Mens Blue Red Plaid Shirt S Classic Button-Down Collar Cotton Blend

$49.39 CERQULAR
CHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual Fit
CERQULAR

CHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Button Down Cotton Blend Casual Fit

$31.19 CERQULAR
Mesh-Paneled Satin-Embroidered Long-Sleeved Shirt
SELDOM SEEN STYLES

Mesh-Paneled Satin-Embroidered Long-Sleeved Shirt

$40.51 SELDOM SEEN STYLES
CHAPS Mens Red & Blue Check Shirt L Button-Down Collar Long Sleeve Cotton Blend
CERQULAR

CHAPS Mens Red & Blue Check Shirt L Button-Down Collar Long Sleeve Cotton Blend

$31.19 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens White Plain Cotton Blend Shirt XL Button Down Collar Long Sleeve
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens White Plain Cotton Blend Shirt XL Button Down Collar Long Sleeve

$22.09 CERQULAR
CHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Cotton Blend Button Down Casual
CERQULAR

CHAPS Mens Blue & White Check Shirt XL Cotton Blend Button Down Casual

$31.19 CERQULAR
RALPH LAUREN Mens Green & White Checked Classic Fit Shirt L Cotton Blend Long
CERQULAR

RALPH LAUREN Mens Green & White Checked Classic Fit Shirt L Cotton Blend Long

$40.29 CERQULAR
CHAPS Mens Orange & Blue Check Shirt L Button-Down Collar Short Sleeve
CERQULAR

CHAPS Mens Orange & Blue Check Shirt L Button-Down Collar Short Sleeve

$31.19 CERQULAR
RALPH LAUREN Mens Blue & Maroon Check Shirt XL Classic Button-Down Cotton
CERQULAR

RALPH LAUREN Mens Blue & Maroon Check Shirt XL Classic Button-Down Cotton

$36.39 CERQULAR
RALPH LAUREN Mens White & Yellow Cotton Check Shirt L Classic Button-Down Collar
CERQULAR

RALPH LAUREN Mens White & Yellow Cotton Check Shirt L Classic Button-Down Collar

$28.59 CERQULAR
NAUTICA Mens Orange Cotton Blend Shirt XL Button-Down Long Sleeve Casual Classic
CERQULAR

NAUTICA Mens Orange Cotton Blend Shirt XL Button-Down Long Sleeve Casual Classic

$25.99 CERQULAR
CHAPS Mens Purple & White Check Shirt 2XL Button Down Long Sleeve Casual Cotton
CERQULAR

CHAPS Mens Purple & White Check Shirt 2XL Button Down Long Sleeve Casual Cotton

$33.79 CERQULAR
TOMMY HILFIGER Mens Red & White Stripe Shirt S Button Down Cotton Casual
CERQULAR

TOMMY HILFIGER Mens Red & White Stripe Shirt S Button Down Cotton Casual

$38.99 CERQULAR
Black Cotton Button Up Shirt with Gold Embroidered Key Motif
THESUPERMADE INC

Black Cotton Button Up Shirt with Gold Embroidered Key Motif

$64.99 THESUPERMADE INC
Worth the splurge5 pieces