Top Picks
Black Slip-on Men's Casual Shoes
MARCUS’ PICK ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.Black Slip-on Men's Casual Shoes
$89.00 ZAPAKA VINTAGE, INC.
Leather Hand-stitched Penny Loafers [Black] (D230810)
TERRY’S PICK W CONCEPTLeather Hand-stitched Penny Loafers [Black] (D230810)
$322.00 W CONCEPT
"Black Men's Classic Patent Loafer - Plain Toe Slip-On Tuxedo Shoe"
TYLER’S PICK EMENSUITS AFFILIATE PROGRAM"Black Men's Classic Patent Loafer - Plain Toe Slip-On Tuxedo Shoe"
$99.00 EMENSUITS AFFILIATE PROGRAM
Men's Cognac Full Leather Lining Vestigium Genuine Ostrich Leg Derby Shoes
JAKE’S PICK ALBERTO NARDONI AFFILIATE PROGRAMMen's Cognac Full Leather Lining Vestigium Genuine Ostrich Leg Derby Shoes
$395.00 ALBERTO NARDONI AFFILIATE PROGRAM
Mens Ostrich Skin Shoes Men's Full Leather Cognac Vestigium Genuine Ostrich Derby Shoes Handcrafted
JAMIE’S PICK ALBERTO NARDONI AFFILIATE PROGRAMMens Ostrich Skin Shoes Men's Full Leather Cognac Vestigium Genuine Ostrich Derby Shoes Handcrafted
$395.00 ALBERTO NARDONI AFFILIATE PROGRAM
How we pick

Nobody here is paid to push a brand. Marcus, Terry, Tyler, Jake and Jamie went through everything in black leather formal shoes the way you would on a lunch break, scrolling, squinting at the fabric, checking the price twice. What made the list is what they'd actually put in their own basket. We look for pieces that wash well, fit properly and don't cost silly money for what they are, and we mix up the shops so you're not just looking at one high street name over and over. Prices and stock come straight from the retailers and change often, so it's always worth a quick check before you buy.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money